Most new writers start with the same question: find a publisher, or do it yourself? Neither route is more “proper” than the other. They simply trade different things. Traditional publishing trades time and control for a team, a budget and physical shelf space. Self-publishing trades money and legwork for speed, ownership and a larger share of every sale. The useful question is not which is better, but which of those trades suits the book you have written and the readers you want to reach.
What the two routes actually involve
Traditional publishing usually means finding an agent first, because most large publishers will not read unagented submissions. You go through a round of submissions, and if an editor likes the book it goes to an acquisitions meeting. Sign the contract, and the production schedule is out of your hands. An editor, cover designer, publicist and sales team then work on your behalf. Smaller independent publishers often accept submissions directly and can move faster.
Self-publishing means becoming the publisher. You commission the editing, the cover and the interior layout, set the price, upload files to platforms such as Amazon KDP, IngramSpark, Apple Books and Kobo, and handle the marketing. Print-on-demand means no boxes of stock under the bed — you order copies when you need them.
There is a middle ground, but tread carefully. A company that asks you to pay a large fee and then takes a share of your rights is not a hybrid publisher in any meaningful sense. If a contract wants money up front and assigns your rights, have it checked before you sign. The Society of Authors and the Alliance of Independent Authors both publish guidance on this.
What each route costs
With traditional publishing, money flows towards the author. You should never pay a publisher to publish your book. Legitimate costs are limited to things like postage for submissions, and your agent takes a commission on what you earn — usually in the region of 15 per cent for UK rights, rising to 20 per cent for translation and some other subsidiary deals.
Self-publishing puts the whole bill in your hands. A realistic budget covers:
- Developmental editing, if the manuscript still needs structural work
- Copy-editing and proofreading — two separate jobs, both worth paying for
- Cover design, including spine and back for the print edition
- Interior formatting for print and ebook files
- ISBNs, which in the UK come from Nielsen; buying your own keeps you free to sell everywhere
- Proof copies, a website, and whatever you decide to spend on advertising
Rates vary with word count, genre and experience, so ask two or three providers for quotes before committing. For a full-length novel, a sensible budget runs into four figures. Treat that as a cost with no guaranteed return, not an investment with a payout.
On contracts and tax: these are areas where professional advice pays for itself. A solicitor who works in publishing, or an accountant who understands royalty income, will usually save you more than they cost.
Advances, royalties and what you take home
Traditional deals normally come with an advance against royalties, paid in instalments — often on signing and again on publication. That advance is exactly what it sounds like: your future royalties, handed over early. Until it has earned out, no further royalty payments come your way. Print royalties are typically a modest percentage of the cover price or of net receipts, your agent’s commission comes off the top, and statements arrive once or twice a year.
Self-publishing pays per sale, usually monthly. Ebook platforms return a substantial share of the list price, and print royalties are calculated as the list price minus printing costs. You set the price, so you control the maths — but you are also responsible for every single sale. Nobody else is putting your book in front of readers.
Either way, royalties are income and need declaring. Keep clean records from the first sale onwards.
Rights: what you keep and what you sign away
You keep the copyright in your work whatever route you take. What differs is the licence you grant.
A traditional contract normally licenses primary rights for a set term, often the life of the edition plus several years, across defined territories. Read closely: does the publisher want world rights or UK and Commonwealth rights, how long does the licence last, how do rights revert if the book goes out of print, and does an option clause tie up your next book? These terms are negotiable, particularly with an agent negotiating for you.
Self-publishing leaves you holding everything — translation, audio, film, serial. That is freedom, and it is also admin. Read platform terms properly: enrolling in programmes such as KDP Select, for example, requires digital exclusivity for the enrolment period. And if a publisher later offers to buy rights in your self-published book, that is a normal, healthy conversation rather than a contradiction.
Distribution and reaching UK readers
Traditional publishers have sales teams, long-standing relationships with chains, wholesalers, supermarkets, online retailers and library suppliers. Their books are returnable, which is largely why shops agree to stock them in the first place.
Self-published authors can achieve wide availability but rarely automatic visibility. Steps that genuinely help:
- Register the book with Nielsen so it carries a UK ISBN and appears in the trade’s bibliographic database. Shops and libraries order from data, not from your website.
- Publish through channels that feed the trade as well as Amazon, rather than relying on one retailer.
- If you want to approach
Photo: Hermann / Pixabay
